In this guide
Give each clue a job
At dawn a watermill stands flooded. The useful conclusion is that water was backed up before the wheel stopped, not that a particular person sabotaged it. A silt line on the inside wall, debris caught on the upstream side of the gate, and the night keeper’s recollection all point to the sequence from different directions.
Give Astra the intended inference, three things players can observe, and a separate list of facts nobody can establish yet. The bent brass latch is interesting, but it could have bent in the flood. Keep it ambiguous until someone finds better evidence. The scenario is a design example, not a measured result for GPT-6.2 Astra or an announcement of support in Playworlds.
Let a failed check change the price, not erase the scene
If a player examines the wall, describe the visible silt line. A successful check might tell them exactly how high the water reached or how recently it fell. On a failure, the timing stays uncertain, or investigating costs time while someone leaves the mill. The keeper and the gate remain available routes; the GM should not relocate clues to make all choices equivalent.
Write each clue as location, visible detail, what it suggests, and what it does not prove. Keep the culprit and motive out of the player-facing description. When a player jumps from ‘water backed up’ to ‘the keeper did it,’ answer with evidence they can pursue, not agreement disguised as a reveal.
Run the case in three orders
Try a party that checks the wall, one that skips straight to the keeper, and one that wrongly accuses the mill owner. Check whether each route returns distinct evidence, whether the mystery can advance with one missing clue, and whether the model resists confirming unsupported accusations.
Before playing, decide what happens if the party walks away. Perhaps the keeper goes home and the gate evidence remains until the next rise. That gives the world a response without forcing a solution. Use the flooded mill as a seed for a separate custom-world mystery.

